Skip to the content

Total Insurance Agency - Appleton, Wisconsin

Total Insurance Agency Provides Auto / Car Insurance, Home Insurance, and Business / Commercial Insurance for Appleton and All of Wisconsin

Total Insurance Agency started as a captive single line agency selling only one line of auto and home insurance. As of August of 2009 we reorganized as an independent agency offering multiple lines of insurance. We feel this is very benefitial to our clients to be able to choose the best fit insurance company for their individual needs. We offer Auto / Car Insurance, Home Insurance, and Business / Commercial Insurance, as well as many special lines products for the more complicated needs of some of our business clients.

Join us for an experience you never had before at the insurance office. If you’re like most people you dread having to even think about insurance stuff. At the Total Insurance Agency, we educate – NOT intimidate. We know if we take the time to educate our client, you can help make decisions about coverages and know why you made them. Intimidation to make a sale is a common practice among many agents. This method of sales leaves you feeling inferior and unsure of what you just purchased and wondering if you made the right choice.

Let’s face it, if we all could afford to lose everything, we own we wouldn’t pay the insurance company to protect it. If our house burned to the ground we would simply build a new one. But for most of us we have to have insurance. We recommend self insuring, but only up to what we can individually afford. At Total Insurance Agency, we find that balance to keep the insurance premiums lower and the out of pocket manageable.

The Total Insurance Agency experience will have you feeling good about your insurance plan as well as understanding what you have and why you have it. Call to have your experience today.

See All Reviews

Appleton Insurance Quotes

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent News & Updates

Cybersecurity Awareness Month: Does Your Business Need Cyber Liability Insurance?

Every October, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) leads Cybersecurity Awareness Month, a nationwide effort to help individuals and organizations better protect themselves online. For small and mid-sized businesses, it's also a timely reminder to think about how a cyberattack or data breach could affect operations, and whether cyber liability insurance has a role to play in your risk management plan. Why Cyber Risk...

Fire Prevention Week: Home Safety Steps and What Your Homeowners Insurance Covers

Every October, the National Fire Protection Association observes Fire Prevention Week, which falls on October 4-10 in 2026. The observance began over a century ago to mark the anniversary of the Great Chicago Fire, and it remains a helpful reminder to check the basics of home fire safety before colder weather sends more people back to their stoves, fireplaces, and space heaters. Common Causes of...

Insurance Considerations for Independent Contractors and Freelancers

Working for Yourself Comes With Its Own Insurance Needs More people than ever are working as independent contractors, consultants, or freelancers, whether as a primary career or a side business. While this type of work often offers flexibility, it also means you're generally responsible for your own insurance protection, since you likely won't have coverage through an employer. Taking time to understand your options early...

Renters Insurance 101: What First-Time Renters Should Know Before Signing a Lease

September Is a Popular Month for New Leases Many apartment leases and off-campus housing arrangements begin in September, as students head to college and young professionals relocate for new jobs. If you're moving into your first apartment this fall, renters insurance is worth understanding before you sign a lease, even though it's easy to overlook amid the excitement of a new place. What Renters Insurance...

Specializing In Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance has been helping customers since 1925 with their auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.